Browse > Home / Christopher Sugrue Bled the Enemy to Death

Christopher Sugrue Bled the Enemy to Death

September 14, 2014

 Welcome to
Musical Instrument Museum

Barrow Puts Peter Steinmetz On Leave
By Ray Stern

The Tragic Three-Day Disappearance of Hiker Eric...
By Ray Stern

New Times Summer Guide 2014
By New Times

The New Segregation: School Choice in AZ Takes New...
By Amy Silverman

A Deputy's Death Opens the Door Onto a World Corruption...
By Stephen Lemons

Who Gets to Chop Off the Head of Tom Horne's Zombie-Like...
By Stephen Lemons

LGBT Advocates Cast a Pall
By Monica Alonzo

The Great Healthcare Heist
By Chris Parker
Before Don Stapley’s Indictment, There Was the Land Deal
A A AComments (10) By Sarah Fenske Thursday, Jan 1 2009

Behind the year's most shocking indictment — 118 criminal counts filed last month against Maricopa County Supervisor Don Stapley — is a bizarre tale of a land deal turned ugly, a $360 million jury verdict reduced to nothing, and a political fundraiser hosted by one of the Valley's most influential law firms.
This particular story-behind-the-story has been playing out for nearly a decade now. But some political insiders believe the tipping point for Stapley may have come in December 2007, when he made the near-fatal mistake of showing up in a courtroom to support an old high school friend.

It wasn't just any high school friend. It was Conley Wolfswinkel, the East Valley land baron who became a poster boy for avarice in the late-'80s savings-and-loan scandal. This time around, Wolfswinkel was being sued by a group of investors over his 2003 purchase of 13,000 acres in Buckeye.

Sheriff's deputies started investigating Don Stapley's financial disclosure forms just a few weeks after his connections with Conley Wolfswinkel were raised in a court hearing.
Sheriff's deputies started investigating Don Stapley's financial disclosure forms just a few weeks after his connections with Conley Wolfswinkel were raised in a court hearing.
Related Stories
Ed Moriarity, Lisa Aubuchon's Ex-Lawyer From Montana, Disbarred in AZ
July 16, 2014
10 Questions Andrew Thomas, GOP Candidate for Governor, Won't Answer
August 6, 2014
Bill Montgomery Lowers Expectations on Charging Decision in Green Acre Dog Deaths, Ticks Off Sheriff Arpaio
September 12, 2014
Lisa Aubuchon and Rachel Alexander Sue Over Debt They Owe in Lawyer-Discipline Case
July 8, 2014
Maricopa County Won't Appeal Ban on Self-Smuggling Prosecutions
July 31, 2014
More About
Don StapleyAndrew ThomasEddie BurkeTrialsCivil Trials
Stapley may have thought he could just quietly sit in the courtroom, listen to the closing arguments, and lend his support.

He was wrong.

The jury returned a huge verdict against Wolfswinkel — but the judge on the case subsequently threw it out. Court records show that, at that point, Stapley's appearance triggered scrutiny from lawyers representing the investors. Stapley's business ties to Wolfs­winkel were raised with the county's presiding judge in a conference call; the investors' lawyers suggested Stapley's presence may have improperly influenced the judge.

Within two weeks of that phone call, County Attorney Andrew Thomas and Sheriff Joe Arpaio initiated their investigation of Stapley. Their probe focused on Stapley's ties to Wolfswinkel.

It might all seem like an amazing coincidence, except for one thing.

One of the land investors, a guy who's spent the past decade trying to stop Conley Wolfswinkel, is Andrew Thomas' attorney.

At this point, there's no way of knowing exactly how the county's investigation into Supervisor Stapley began. At their joint news conference to discuss the case last month, Sheriff Arpaio and County Attorney Thomas said only that they'd received a "tip," and that the investigation started in May.

Many insiders believe the source of that tip is Thomas' attorney, Leo Beus, a prominent guy in the Mormon community and partner in a firm that represents most of the big developers in town. But in a phone call with New Times, Beus flatly denied ever talking to Thomas about the case.

"I have no idea how Andrew Thomas got any information about it," he says. "I never, ever spoke to Andrew Thomas about this." Beus adds that he considers Stapley a friend.

"I have no desire to do him any harm at all," he says.

Dan Dowd, one of the attorneys representing Beus' investor group on the deal, says the same thing: "Our office never had discussions with the county attorney on any of this."

That certainly may be true. But the facts point to, at minimum, one hell of a coincidence.

Here's what the record shows, according to court files, county financial records, and campaign finance filings.

In 2007, Andrew Thomas hired Beus and his partner, Paul Gilbert, to represent him in a showdown with the State Bar of Arizona.

At the time, Thomas was facing 13 different Bar complaints. The Bar wasn't happy about how Thomas had sought to stop Judge Timothy Ryan from hearing all criminal cases because of Ryan's stance on immigration. Nor did the Bar appreciate comments Thomas had made to the media, criticizing the judiciary, or his appointment of a special prosecutor with clear conflicts of interest in the botched New Times investigation. (See "Andrew Thomas Fights to Seal Wilenchik's State Bar Secrets," June 26, 2008.)

Thomas was in the fight of his political life. And Beus proved to be just the right attorney to help Thomas win it.

Beus' selection initially surprised insiders. His firm is a powerful one — but it specializes in land-use issues.

No matter. Beus took on the task of defending Thomas with an intensity far beyond the usual role of a lawyer. He took the Bar to task in the media, in a special action to the state Supreme Court, and in conversation to anyone who would listen. With Dan Cracchiolo, his co-counsel on the matter, Beus even paid for a full-page ad in Arizona Attorney, the Bar's in-house magazine, claiming the Bar was on a witch hunt.

"We write this letter, not as Mr. Thomas' attorneys, and pay for this space at our own personal expense because we have something to say that all Arizona lawyers may want to hear," they wrote.

In direct response to Beus' complaints, the Bar agreed to remove its chief counsel from the case and appoint an independent investigator; sources tell New Times the case against Thomas has been foundering ever since. Score one for Leo Beus.

Over the past five years, Beus and his lawyers brought the same relentlessness to their fight against Conley Wolfswinkel — the legal battle that would eventually draw Supervisor Don Stapley to the courtroom as a spectator.

The issue is a land deal. Beus was part of a group of investors that owned 10,000 acres in the West Valley. In 1998, the managers of that group entered into contracts to purchase another 3,000 acres and then sell the whole parcel to a company called Breycliffe. The price: $5,000 an acre, plus 20 percent of the profit if Breycliffe was able to sell it to a developer.

1 2 3 All | Next Page »
Related Content
 Don’t be distracted by the Sharks. Look for the Snails Paid Distribution
Don’t be distracted by the Sharks. Look for the Snails
Recommended by

to Friend    Write to
Editor    Print

 My Voice Nation  Help

Sign in or Create Account1 person listening
+ Follow
Post comment as...
Newest | Oldest | Top Comments
Maricopa County Audit needed o
Maricopa County Audit needed o Mar 24, 2009
How does the maricopa county sheriff's office not get audited in 12 years? Let's see a list of those culprits. Slash the PR budget in the MCSO and MCAO office's. They are using our taxpayer dollars to destroy US!! Wake up people!!

Maricopa County Audit needed o
Maricopa County Audit needed o Mar 24, 2009
How does the maricopa county sheriff's office not get audited in 12 years? Let's see a list of those culprits. Slash the PR budget in the MCSO and MCAO office's. They are using our taxpayer dollars to destroy US!! Wake up people!!

WarPig Feb 5, 2009
This is not the first time that Stapley has been investigated, and it was before Andrew Thomas was even in office. I think the Times might have a little "skin in the game" given their past with Thomas and Arpaio. While the Times' anti-Arpaio/Thomas stance might be justified, can they really write an unbiased article about what is going on with Stapely. Why not look into some of the land deals between Conley, via his puppets: Brandon, Ashton, Candice etc., and Stapely, instead of just saying they are old high school buddies.

david saint is disgusted at th
david saint is disgusted at th Jan 5, 2009
while the rest of the country is moving forward, AZ is taking 100 steps back. While i know it would probably only take one person in a position higher than theirs to take these 2 clowns to court, i fear no one ever will and the reign of terror and fascism will only increase. I once hoped that incoming president Obama and staff might take a serious look at him, but with all thats going on in the country with financial meltdowns, etc, i think its going to take a long time before anyone does something about these 2. Its really a travesty, but in this day and age not something new. Lets face it, while the reality show probably will suck like a van buren hooker, its going to get him fans becuase they just dont know the real deal behind him..mostly because anytime someone here locally prints it or just speaks about it, they end up investigated or arrested on some charge they arent convicted of anyways..thats where the disgust comes into play..a sheriff and DA in NC both got in trouble for doing similar things (DA on the Duke case, and the sheriff for saying some borderline racial comments), and they got press for the negativity..yet arpaio and thomas have done much worse yet NOTHING...why????? if we can answer that question (and dont tell me the 400k a year PR team..they suck so bad they make hookers jealous by comparison) then maybe we'd figure out why its gone on for so long with out so much as a freakin audit of county money in 12 YEARS!!!

marvin Dec 31, 2008
Again the only place you can turn to for the whole story and the truth is the PHoenix New Times.Thank you for this very informative article I am just wondering what it is going to take to get the Arpaio and Thomas followers to see the light,? Certainly figures that a bunch of crooked slimey lawyers would put money in his campaign, who else?

Coz Dec 31, 2008
And to think that the majority of voters in Arizona approve of these 2 morons since they were just re-elected...

Sure doesn't say much for the mentality of Maricopa County residents.

Seems Arizona thrives, respects and looks up to Corrupt Politicians.

Pretty sad...

TimeToGoJoe Dec 31, 2008
Integrity of a man is tested when he is confronted with double standards. Should Andrew Thomas ignore Arpaio's faulty financial disclosures when prosecuting Stapley for the same thing, it will completely and without question demonstrate that Mr. Thomas does not have the integrity required to be out county attorney. In this office, absolute integrity should be and must be a requirement. Apparently, all Thomas and Arpaio need to start an investigation is a "tip." Have they got a tip on Arpaio's financial disclosres yet? We know that Arpaio does not read the papers and believes they should be trashed. Maybe there is not knowledge about Arpaio's alleged faulty disclosures without an "official tip."

There are numerous examples of Mr. Thomas appearing to not have the required integrity to be county attorney. This article and many others in this and other publications demonstrate a lesson to all. If you are cross-ways with Thomas, you will be investigated and at best, it will cost you a lot of money.

observer Dec 31, 2008
This is unacceptable and totally inappropriate behavior for a County Attorney.

Excerpt from article: "The same week that sheriff's deputies pulled Stapley's disclosure forms, Beus and his partner, Paul Gilbert, threw a fundraiser for Andrew Thomas at Gilbert's home.

Sheriff's deputies started investigating Don Stapley's financial disclosure forms just a few weeks after his connections with Conley Wolfswinkel were raised in a court hearing.

Subject(s):Don Stapley, Conley Wolfswinkel --The people contributing the maximum amount to Thomas' campaign include Beus, Gilbert, a host of lawyers from the firm that handled their case against Wolfswinkel, and at least three other investors who were burned by Judge Burke's verdict."

And they think Illinois is corrupt?? Sarah, keep on digging. You are very courageous and to be commended. We thank you very much.

State of Fear AZ
State of Fear AZ Dec 31, 2008
Sarah, outstanding investigative work. You and Phoenix New Times are doing a great public service keeping us informed and connecting the dots of the corruption in Arizona. Stapley should be given the presumption of innocence until the facts are presented. It looks like you presented the facts on Thomas' lawyer and his connections.

When are we going to see the Arizona Bar v Thomas? Abuse of power by an attorney who has no ethics should be punished, for violating the public trust and exploiting the people. The policies Thomas has created should be used against him, like zero tolerance, mandatory minimum sentencing - 10 years flat time first offense on a plea bargain, if he dares take his case to trial, he should get a million years like others who dare go to trial.

It's time to save the community from the County Attorney and Sheriff. They are out of control.

Coz Dec 31, 2008
If it looks like shit, smells like shit and walks like shit, it must be Candy Dandy Thomas and Bozo Joe Arpaio.

What a couple of corrupt scumbags these 2 are.

Powered by Livefyre
Now Trending
 Cannabis Researcher's Firing Looks Political Cannabis Researcher's Firing Looks Political
 Exposed: Anti-Casino Signature Gathering Campaign Misleading Some Glendale Residents Exposed: Anti-Casino Signature Gathering Campaign Misleading Some Glendale Residents
 Atheists Blast Jan Brewer for Her Creation of an "Office of Faith and Community Partnerships" Atheists Blast Jan Brewer for Her Creation of an "Office of Faith and Community Partnerships"

Linkin Park at U.S Airways Center
Club Candids: Tongue Tied's Under the Sea Dance at Apollo's
Infected Mushroom at Monarch Theatre
More Slideshows >>

 Sean Noble, GOP Strategist, Calls on Russell Pearce to Resign for His Remarks on the Coerced Sterilization of Women
 Top Five Most-Read Phoenix News Stories of the Week
 Bill Montgomery Works to Free Prisoner Ray Chatman, Who Killed Man in 1970
More News Stories >
Best of Phoenix
2013 - People & Places

 Best Place to Find a Vintage Treasure Best Place to Find a Vintage Treasure
Burton Barr Central Library
 Best Vintage Film Series Best Vintage Film Series
Orpheum Theatre
More People & Places Awards >
Special Reports
Florence Exposed
Yarnell Hill Fire: Investigating the Deaths of 19 Granite Mountain Hotshots
Amy's Baking Company - A History of Kitchen Nightmares - The Original Story by Phoenix New Times
Jodi Arias's Kinky Murder Trial in Arizona
Arpaio Racial Profiling
Sheriff Joe Archive
Babeu Revealed
Arizona's Centennial
Amongst U.S.
Vintage McCain
Target Practice
Wrecking Phoenix
Shadow Dwellers
Scandal at the Housing Authority
Prescription for Disaster
Polygamy in Arizona
Murder City
Major Articles on Joe Arpaio
Green Fatigue
Exploding Downtown
Drive At Your Own Risk
Deconstructing Janet
Crossing the Line
Cracked Houses
Chronic Truth
More Special Reports >>
©2014 Phoenix New Times, LLC, All rights reserved.
Musical Instrument Museum
Phoenix New TimesMore From Voice NationJoinSign In